Indianapolis · Emergency room care
Emergency room care in Indianapolis: what the hospital owed you, and who the claim is against
An emergency department owes everyone who comes in an appropriate medical screening examination within the capability of the hospital’s emergency department (opens in a new tab), and anyone with an emergency condition such treatment as may be required to stabilize the medical condition (opens in a new tab). This page sets out that duty, who the claim is against, and Indiana’s clock.
The short answer
What does an Indianapolis emergency room owe a patient under the law?
Two things, by federal statute. When a person comes to the emergency department and asks for examination or treatment, the hospital must provide for an appropriate medical screening examination within the capability of the hospital’s emergency department (opens in a new tab), and if there is an emergency medical condition, such treatment as may be required to stabilize the medical condition (opens in a new tab) before any transfer. Whether the care that followed met the standard of care is a separate question, answered from the chart under Indiana law, usually by a medical review panel first.
What does federal law require of an emergency department?
The Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act applies to hospitals with emergency departments that take Medicare. The hospital must provide for an appropriate medical screening examination within the capability of the hospital’s emergency department, including ancillary services routinely available to the emergency department (opens in a new tab), to find out whether an emergency medical condition exists. If one does, it must give such treatment as may be required to stabilize the medical condition (opens in a new tab), or transfer the patient on the statute’s conditions.
The statute gives the patient a claim of its own against the hospital: any individual who suffers personal harm as a direct result of a participating hospital’s violation of a requirement of this section may, in a civil action against the participating hospital, obtain those damages available for personal injury under the law of the State in which the hospital is located (opens in a new tab). It has its own limit: no action may be brought under this paragraph more than two years after the date of the violation (opens in a new tab).
Who is the claim against?
It may be more than one provider. A single visit can involve the hospital, a physician from an outside group, a nurse, a radiologist reading from elsewhere and an ambulance crew, and an emergency ambulance service is itself on the Act’s list of health care providers (opens in a new tab). Each has its own employer and its own status under the Act.
So each is checked. The Act covers a provider who has qualified, and one who has not is subject to liability under the law without regard to this article (opens in a new tab). The Fund’s public database (opens in a new tab) is a place to start. If the emergency department belongs to a public hospital, the page on public hospitals has a much shorter date to know about.
What does the emergency room chart show?
An emergency record is built on times: triage, the first physician contact, each order, each result and when it was read, the medications and the discharge. You have a right to it. A provider must supply it within thirty days after the date the written request is made (opens in a new tab), and the federal rule sets the same outer limit (opens in a new tab).
The gaps are often the case: a result posted and not read, a reassessment ordered and not done, a discharge before a test came back. Ask for the complete record, including the nursing notes and the test results rather than the discharge paperwork alone.
How long does an emergency room patient have?
For most claims against a provider, two years after the date of the alleged act, omission, or neglect (opens in a new tab), which for an emergency visit is usually the date on the chart. The federal claim over the screening and stabilization duties has its own two years after the date of the violation (opens in a new tab).
A claim against a qualified provider then goes to a medical review panel, whose members read the same chart. And one rule of the Act is written for emergencies: the sections on written consent do not cover every case, and the Act says it does not require consent to health care in an emergency (opens in a new tab). A claim about an emergency procedure is usually about the care itself.
Indiana’s Good Samaritan statute protects a person who gratuitously renders emergency care at the scene of the emergency or accident (opens in a new tab). It does not apply to services rendered by a health care provider (opens in a new tab) to a patient in a health care facility, so it is not an answer to a claim over care in an emergency department.
Frequently asked questions
The emergency room sent me home and I got worse. Is that a case?
It might be. The questions are whether the hospital gave an appropriate medical screening examination (opens in a new tab) and whether the care met the standard, and the chart answers both. Ask for the whole record and have it read.
Does it matter that I could not pay?
Federal law says a hospital may not delay provision of an appropriate medical screening examination (opens in a new tab) in order to ask about payment or insurance status. If that happened, tell the lawyer who reads your chart.
How long do I have after an emergency room visit?
For most claims, two years after the date of the alleged act, omission, or neglect (opens in a new tab), which is usually the date of the visit. A public hospital can bring a much earlier notice date, so check who runs the hospital.
Can the hospital use the Good Samaritan law against me?
Not for care inside a hospital: the statute does not apply to services rendered by a health care provider (opens in a new tab) to a patient in a health care facility.
Keep reading
- 01
Indiana law
The clock, the panel, who the Act covers and what is local, in brief, with the full Indiana guide.
Indiana law page - 02
Marion County courts
When a claim reaches a court, which county the rules prefer, and Marion County’s own part in the Act.
Explore Marion County courts - 03
Federal and VA care
The written claim to the agency within two years, the sum it must state, the wait, and what the United States pays.
Explore federal and VA care - 04
Public hospitals
Whether the Medical Malpractice Act governs, the 180-day notice if it does not, and what the notice must say.
Explore public hospitals
Last stop