Indianapolis · The courts
Where an Indianapolis medical malpractice case is filed, and when it gets there
An Indianapolis malpractice claim usually reaches a courthouse last. It starts as a proposed complaint with the Commissioner of Insurance (opens in a new tab), goes to a medical review panel, and only then to a court. This page sets out which court, which county, and why Marion County has a part in the Act of its own.
The short answer
Where is an Indianapolis medical malpractice case filed?
First with the Commissioner of Insurance, as a proposed complaint, if the provider is qualified under the Act. After the medical review panel’s opinion, a patient may file a complaint in any court of law having requisite jurisdiction (opens in a new tab) and demand a jury. In Indianapolis that is usually the Marion Superior Court or the Marion Circuit Court. Indiana’s Rule 75 says any case may be venued, commenced and decided in any court in any county (opens in a new tab), subject to a timely motion to move it to a county of preferred venue.
Which court hears the case?
Marion County constitutes the nineteenth judicial circuit (opens in a new tab), with a Circuit Court, and the statute has also established a superior court in Marion County (opens in a new tab) with thirty-six judges. The court says its courthouse, opened in April 2022 (opens in a new tab), stands on the Community Justice Campus at 675 Justice Way on the southeast side of the city (opens in a new tab), and has 71 courtrooms, including 11 jury rooms (opens in a new tab).
A claim against a qualified provider gets there after the panel. The patient may then file a complaint in any court of law having requisite jurisdiction (opens in a new tab) and, by demand, exercise the right to a trial by jury (opens in a new tab). The claim may also be filed in court while the panel works, with no information that would allow a third party to identify the defendant (opens in a new tab), and the case waits.
Which county can the case be brought in?
Indiana’s rule starts wide. Any case may be venued, commenced and decided in any court in any county (opens in a new tab), and it can then be moved if a party files a timely motion and the county does not meet the rule’s preferred venue. Preferred venue includes the county where the greater percentage of individual defendants included in the complaint resides (opens in a new tab), and the county where the principal office of a defendant organization (opens in a new tab) is located, or the office to which the claim relates or out of which the claim arose (opens in a new tab).
Many claims over Indianapolis care fit Marion County on those terms. The proposed complaint has to name a county too: the Department of Insurance says the county of venue should be designated in the proposed complaint (opens in a new tab), and the chair of the panel can come from a list of attorneys with offices in the county of venue designated in the proposed complaint or in a contiguous county (opens in a new tab).
Why does Marion County have a part of its own in the Act?
Because the state’s agency is here. When a provider or its insurer has agreed to pay its limit and the claimant wants more from the Patient’s Compensation Fund, the petition goes to the court named in the proposed complaint or, at the claimant’s election (opens in a new tab), to the circuit or superior court of Marion County (opens in a new tab). A patient anywhere in Indiana can make that choice.
The Commissioner’s own motion goes here as well. If nothing has happened in a case at the Department for at least two years, the Commissioner may file a motion in Marion county circuit court to dismiss the case (opens in a new tab), on a party’s motion or on the Commissioner’s own initiative. A claim that is left to sit can end that way.
What about federal court?
A claim over the care of a federal employee ends up there, after the agency has had it. Marion County is in the Southern District of Indiana, whose Indianapolis Division (opens in a new tab) holds court in the city. The page on federal and VA care sets out the steps.
Frequently asked questions
Does the case have to be filed in Marion County?
No. Under Rule 75 any case may be venued, commenced and decided in any court in any county (opens in a new tab), and a defendant can then ask to move it to a county of preferred venue, which depends on who the defendants are and where they are.
Do I go to court first?
Not on a claim against a qualified provider. An action may not be commenced in a court in Indiana (opens in a new tab) until the claim has gone to a panel and the panel has given its opinion, unless an exception applies.
Where is the courthouse?
The Marion County Courthouse is at 675 Justice Way on the southeast side of the city (opens in a new tab), on the Community Justice Campus.
What happens if a claim sits at the Department for years?
The Commissioner may file a motion in Marion county circuit court to dismiss the case (opens in a new tab) if no action has been taken for at least two years, so a claim has to keep moving.
Keep reading
- 01
Indiana law
The clock, the panel, who the Act covers and what is local, in brief, with the full Indiana guide.
Indiana law page - 02
Federal and VA care
The written claim to the agency within two years, the sum it must state, the wait, and what the United States pays.
Explore federal and VA care - 03
Public hospitals
Whether the Medical Malpractice Act governs, the 180-day notice if it does not, and what the notice must say.
Explore public hospitals - 04
Emergency room care
The screening and stabilization the law requires, why each provider is checked, and Indiana’s clock.
Explore emergency room care
Last stop